Registered charity 1059047 (unmaintained legacy site – official site: www.nawg.co.uk)

The National Association of Writers' Groups

HomeServices ♦ Critiquing Service

Critiquing Service

We on the NAWG committee are delighted to announce the launch of our new critiquing service. As you'll see below we have a range of writers / tutors offering professional advice across many genres together with various critiquing packages to suit your requirements and budget. Note too that our prices compare very favourably with other critiquing services out there in the marketplace.

How It Works

Simply choose which critiquing option you want together with your critiquer of choice. In the first instance send an email or letter to Steve Bowkett indicating your preferences. Also tell us at this stage how long the piece of work will be that you are going to send. This will allow us to give you a price for the service. We will write back to you with this figure before you commit yourself to a critique.

Once you are happy to go ahead, send an email with your work attached to editor@nawg.co.uk. Please include your address in the email. Steve will then send you a contract to sign through the post, which confirms your requirements. Return the contract with payment to:

Old Vicarage

This may be a cheque made payable to NAWG, or a BACS payment for the appropriate amount. Our bank details are:

Washington Town Centre Branch
NE38 7SG
Sort code: 60-22-52
Account: 80275877

Please indicate on the contract how you are paying. Once we have received your signed contract the work will be forwarded to your chosen tutor. If you do not have email access, send your work and which package / tutor you want to the NAWG Peterborough address. We will then send your contract for signing.

We will send your completed critique to you via email or through the post. Note that tutors cannot enter into correspondence with regard to a critique. If you have any subsequent queries or are in any way dissatisfied please contact Steve.

Your critique will be sent as soon as possible, though obviously this will depend on which package you have chosen and the tutor's other commitments. If you would like an indication of when you can expect to receive your critique please mention this at the outset and we will pass on your request to the tutor.

We hope you feel that the critiquing service is a step forward for NAWG and its members. If you have any suggestions as to how we can improve the service even further please let Steve know.

Our Critiquers

Here is a list of our tutors. You can click on some of the names to go to their mini biography or visit their website.

Name Genres & Areas of Expertise
Brad Ashton Comedy and advice on public speaking.
Julie Bokowiec Play scripts. Note that Julie's advice requires a face-to-face meeting.
Steve Bowkett Writing for children; writing Horror, Fantasy, SF for children and adults; poetry (beginners); proposal advice for educational projects.
Alison Chisholm Poetry and poetry markets. Autobiography.
Malcolm Chisholm Advice on design and publishing your free website (using weebly.com); use of the internet, research, Facebook, Linkedin, Twitter; self-publishing with print-on-demand (POD) services (using lulu.com).
Marvin Close TV drama (adult and children's); theatre; radio (drama, comedy and documentary, as writer and producer); non-fiction books (particularly in the general areas of history and sport); advice on markets and placing particular pieces.
Linda Lewis Fiction and non-fiction (please indicate if you have a particular market in mind).
Maureen Raper Writing for pleasure and profit. Writing for children. Writing life stories.
Roz Southey Crime novel in particular, and novels in general, principally for adults.
Simon Whaley Non-fiction articles, non-fiction book proposals, non-fiction books such as personal travel memoirs, biographies and autobiographies.
Tim Wilson Full-length fiction.

Packages and Prices

Package Description Price
Picture book text All other text
Quick feedback A quick and inexpensive 'first glance' impression to let you know if you are basically on track with your work. £30 per hour, including reading time and writing up comments.
Detailed assessment A much lengthier and in-depth report on the work being considered. £30 for the first hour, £15 per hour subsequently. £15 per 1,000 words for first 5,000 words then £10 per 1,000 words thereafter.
Q-A / Email exchange Here the tutor responds to specific questions the client has about his/her submission. In practice some of the replies would be brief and straightforward while others would go into much more detail. £25 per hour reading time. £30 for the first hour of responding to questions and £20 per hour thereafter.
Pre-submission check Here the tutor would look through a piece that you are happy with and about to submit to an agent, publisher, competition etc. The aim here is to cast a fresh pair of eyes over the piece just to check editorial guidelines, competition rules etc have been met. £25 per hour reading/responding time.


We can also offer workshops, subject to a tutor's other commitments. Please email Steve for further details, your requirements etc. Fees for a workshop are:

  • £200 per day,
  • £125 half day,
  • £95 for an evening event,

all plus travel.

Note that prices where applicable are on a pro rata basis, so that if for example a quick feedback took 45 minutes you would be charged £20 rather than £30.

Article Actions
Article Information
Posted by: Kevin Machin Date: January 29, 2016 7:04 pm
Categories: Services Tags: None
Comments: 0 – permitted Article: 4345 – public, sticky
Legacy copy – all further commenting is disabled site-wide.

article as:

Get Creative logo

Competition & Mentorships

We are proud to be associated with the Highlands & Islands Short Story Association.



  • Book Printing
  • Self Publishing
  • Anthologies
  • Hard and Soft Back Book Production
  • Free guide and sample book

CMP (uk) Ltd

G3 The Fulcrum, Vantage Way, Poole, Dorset, BH12 4HU

Telephone: 01202 739993